Eidderf's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[ZSL Extravaganzafestathon]

Good Job

I didn't know so many people created a part, turned out quite well in the end though, some fun little things in there.

[Anigen The Bee]

Amazing, but let down by teh small things

Honestly I'm a big fan of frame by frame animation and this is a beautiful example of that, if only you had kept it in proportion. The right arm (that I will refer to as arm Bee) holding the firearm seems be unfortunately smaller than it should be, I don't know if this problem was identified too late in production to correct or if the animator suffered an injury like a sting to the hand but it's a real shame that something so minor ruined the overall experience. Still I can see why there is such a BUZZ around this animation. Keep it up.

[SD 06: Death of P-Bot]

Nice

It's a pity you didn't finish this, the fight scene at the end was quite good, with the spinning 3D hammer thing.

[The Box by Michelle Denz]

Not bad

It wasn't a bad cartoon, it had some nice visuals, an unusual if basic story and sound fitting voice acting. Although you've obviously put a lot of time and effort into drawing the flash I found that the animation itself was kind of basic, there wasn't much fbf stuff and some parts seemed a little clunky. I also thought that when he went inside the box the drawings weren't very creepy and spoiled the atmosphere of the animation, if the creatures weren't so basic in the box then it would be a more fitting end. Still it was a decent enough animation and hope to see more of your stuff in the future.

mizskellington responds:

thanks for your review, and I completely agree. I spent too much time on the art work aspect and therefore the animation suffered a little...

[Nineteen Hippos]

Nice job

I didn't know what to expect from this flash, but it was good, nice shorts with a lot of style, well done.

Happy Birthday Bluehippo

[Circadian Dysrhythmia]

I got a Trojan vi....I mean good Job

A nice toon ZL, some great frame by frame animations and backgrounds although the plot (as you said) just wasn't there. Even though the movie did not make much sense I did find the end a bit cut short, like you just got bored and stopped animating. The audio matched the toon perfectly, the lack of audio effects sort of added to the atmosphere created by the robot world. Anyway good job there.